A 911 call comes in from a woman who says her neighbor is not breathing and covered in blood, then police find 69-year-old Benjamin dead, his house in disarray and money missing, but as detectives search for answers, another murder occurs.

After a man calls 911 to report being stabbed and a house on fire, police find Ron Whiles shot and burned in his home in Lafayette, Ind.; with one victim dead and one clinging to life, detectives question multiple suspects, which leads to one name.