Rudy and Samuel are rehearsing for Mr Beakman's play The Prize Potato. Muffin wants to be in the play, too, but there is no part for her. That is, until the props get blown away! Muffin becomes the star of the show, playing a hat, a potato and a watering can.

Samuel and Rudy are playing, but they can't agree on what to do. Mr Beakman tells them that there must be something they both like. Muffin leads Rudy and Samuel to Missy's house where everyone agrees on dressing up!