Samuel and Muffin go to the Amazing Beakman's magic show, and Muffin is blown away by his tricks. She goes around the neighbourhood trying to perform her own trick, but it doesn't work out. Just as she is about to give up, Mr Beakman encourages her, and the two put on a magic show together, where Muffin makes Mr Beakman disappear.

Muffin stumbles on Samuel and Rudy's playhouse, but they won't let her come in. She stomps away and Quinn helps her build her own playhouse, even better than theirs. When Samuel and Rudy ask to visit, Muffin won't let them. Mr Beakman suggests they stop quarrelling and put the playhouses together. They take his advice and make the best playhouse ever.