While Jo is a struggling writer with a casual job, Alice has achieved her childhood dream as a world-renowned cellist. Struck by Alice's coolness towards her, Jo is compelled to revisit the past, recalling their arrival at Silver Creek.

Red House is reunited in the present day at the funeral of their peer Emma, one of the few girls they all remember warmly despite their different memories of Silver Creek. Jo attempts to forge a healthier path for herself.