When Kat gets selected as a finalist for the Louisville Courier Journal's "Twenty under Forty" list, she decides to join the local gym to try to get in shape. Meanwhile, Randi and Daniel struggle to take their relationship to the next level and Phil deals with the realization that one of his favorite childhood books is racist.

When Randi's cousin comes to town, Kat and Phil convince Randi to let them come out with her to prove they aren't old. Meanwhile, Randi struggles to figure out why Daniel doesn't get jealous.