Someone snatches a student from her college campus in Indiana, while a second missing girl turns up dead months later. Then, terrified girls report a man trying to lure them into his van, but is he the real killer? Police wonder until one man confesses.

New York City firefighters discover the headless bodies of two sex workers, leading the tabloids to dub the perpetrator the "Times Square Killer." Now, investigators must find a way to hunt down a psychopath adept at blending into his surroundings.