The more the merrier! As Chad, Faith, and Garrett are introduced to new—and for some, not-so-new—eligible singles, their suitors seize the opportunity to connect…with each other. Later, the party winds down as our singles grapple with the difficult decision to send someone home for good.

Before Chad, Faith, and Garrett can wine and dine a mystery suitor for their eighth date of Christmas, Garrett receives a sweet surprise. Later, when someone from Faith's past reenters the picture, what's to become of her future with Anthony? Meanwhile, the arrival of a gregarious new housemate puts the others on edge.