Our 3 Amigos struggle with the strict rules and institutionalized homophobia of their new Catholic reform school, especially when Chucky arrives with a murderous agenda. Meanwhile, in Beverly Hills, a suspicious detective threatens Tiffany's imposture as "Jennifer Tilly" and the discovery of her secret hostage, Nica Pierce.

Tiffany's secrets are threatened by the return from college of her 18-year-old kids Glen and Glenda, and by a surprise intervention conducted by several of Jennifer Tilly's loved ones, who are concerned about their old friend's odd behavior.