Don visits a sleepy Virginia town where paranormal activity is spiking and finds a connection to the Lost Colony of Roanoke. He retraces the path of a mysterious relic as he explores whether dark magic from the Old World doomed settlers in the New World.

Don investigates an ancient cult by undergoing its most-terrifying ritual in Peru. He finds evidence of a supernatural war in remote caves and uncovers clues about bloody human sacrifices, revealing the truth behind a dangerous and secretive religion.