Charlie is tempted to change his clean reputation when a group of school vandals invites him into their clique, forcing Dylan to try to change Charlie's mind. Rebecca and Bethany protest when they are not allowed on the football team.

Dylan insists that playing baseball isn't another one of his fleeting interests, but when he decides he wants to quit after only a few days, he has to hide the decision from the family. Rebecca struggles to choose something for her class time capsule.