After the events of the previous night, the teens split up to find evidence confirming their suspicions. Nico finds Tina's staff, and Gert and Chase find the dinosaur in the Yorkes' basement. Meanwhile, Catherine questions Molly about whether she was in Geoffrey's study or not.

The teens chase after the abducted Alex and reveal their powers to each other. Meanwhile, Geoffrey avoids telling Catherine about Darius, and the parents get a new sacrifice.