Cora has been contacted by an old crush from high school who shows up, and to her surprise, he proposes; Leah gets concerned when Jeremy starts coming home later than usual and spending time with single friends she's never met.

Reginald shocks the Pleasant Days crew when he begins behaving in uncharacteristic ways; Efe knows why but struggles to keep Reginald's secret; Karen challenges Vinny to a cook-off.