A grisly murder in Rome, Georgia would leave this conservative town reeling. Thad Reynolds, loving husband, father of four and deacon at Hollywood Baptist Church was stabbed 19 times in his office.

As best friends Brian Ognjan and David Tyll arrived in Mio, Michigan for a hunting trip, the two men had no idea they'd end up as prey. The 18-year investigation that followed would reveal a tale of wrong turns, bullying brothers and a wood chipper.