The spring of 2005 would bring a horrifying end to the town of Iaeger's peace and tranquility when beloved physician Doc Whitley was found burned to death in his home. The investigation would blow the top on the town's darkest secrets.

In 1989, Jeni Gray inexplicably vanished while on a morning walk in Boone. Police were perplexed when no trace of Jeni could be found in town or the surrounding area. But that confusion gave way to horror when a second woman disappeared.