Tom and Connor vie to prove to Denise which of them would make a better sperm donor. Meanwhile, Sarah tries to prove to Alison that she has what it takes to direct the spring musical by throwing a successful fundraiser at Connor's house.

While Tom and Sarah work on writing a musical for Windmount Academy, things get physical when they don't see eye to eye on the flow of the script. Marina and Denise turn to Connor to help get into better physical shape.