Always looking for an opportunity to send it, Kyle is enraged to find his housemates have more laid back plans for their Saturday night than he'd prefer. The teacher becomes the student when Lindsay finally receives a grand gesture from Stephen. Carl returns from Pittsburgh to find the house in shambles after Hannah and Kyle's most explosive fight yet.

It's a house divided for Girls' and Guys' Night. Lindsay and Luke's maybe-not-so-innocent friendship is called into question when Amanda and Paige confront them about the juicy hookup rumor. But the party must go on as the housemates organize a bar crawl through their rooms, where sparks fly between Ciara and Carl, who slips up and puts his sobriety at risk. Finally, all hell breaks loose when the guys corner Luke and demand he account for his behavior.