Dwight goes sleuthing when three gun-toting thieves rob a party boat, but there are ripple effects when the case involves one of Dwight's oldest friends. Fallout from the investigation allows Dwight to reconnect with an ex-flame and perform music with an old bandmate.

Dwight and Whitehead hightail it to a local bank, where a man has taken hostages and claims that he's the victim of a scam. As Dwight works the delicate case, he soon unearths deep truths about the alleged scam. Meanwhile, Paula Ann suffers a breakup.