Mike and Frank kick off their journey in upstate New York, where they meet Frank, a retired firefighter with rare fire memorabilia that's tough to track down. Next, Mike heads to Ohio, uncovering the biggest bike collection he's ever seen. Then they meet Mary, who owns a farm with outbuildings--once a smokehouse, while others remain frozen in time. The episode wraps up back in New York, where they meet Fran, an accountant with a serious collecting obsession.

Stashes of super-sized collections are unearthed when Mike and Frank stumble upon a treasure trove of motorcycles and then find themselves waist deep in two massive hangars brimming with rare relics while Mike and Jersey trip out over an Oddfellow's Lodge in Maryland, chock full of rooms and rooms of hidden treasures.