Newlyweds in Lancaster, Pa., dream of buying a spacious home for their extended family. Their wishes are put to the test as she pushes for a move-in-ready Colonial and he insists on getting the split-level home of his childhood, even if it needs work.

A couple disagree over buying a house with a pool or being right on the water in Tampa. And since neither option comes cheap, they might be getting a fixer-upper to boot.