A tight knit Orthodox Jewish community is terrified when police respond to a mother's 911 call from her ransacked house to break down the locked bedroom door of her daughter, 18 year old Aliza, to find Aliza naked and dead on the floor.

At only 17, Catherine left hometown Ohio to come to New York with a dream of dancing on Broadway. Three short years later she is found viciously stabbed to death in her Manhattan apartment, inches from a critical hidden clue.