When a popular teacher is stabbed in her Staten Island home, NYPD officers in this close-knit community embark on a quest for justice, uncovering a web of secrets and lies behind closed doors that leave even the most seasoned detectives reeling.

In the 1990s, a group of over-the-top misfits known as the Club Kids rule New York's downtown club scene. After a beloved member goes missing, a gruesome rumor circulates and detectives uncover a seedy world of drugs, debauchery and murder.