A couple is found dead in a quiet Bucks County home leaving Detective Christopher Petrowski to follow some small but very ironic leads. Petrowski questions a young girl whom he finds oddly familiar though can't he place why or from where.

An unexpected high-priced attorney comes to the rescue of the Meth-dealing Will Pepper, forcing Petrowski's Captain to let him walk. Petrowski visits the site of a former cold case, bumping into the girl from the Walsh crime scene and does some off the record surveillance.