Captain Sandy returns to Croatia at the helm of the mega-yacht Lady Michelle in hopes of guiding a new team through calmer waters along the stunning Dalmatian Coast. Previously a Chef to celebrities and the uber-wealthy, Mathew takes over the galley, where his ambitions quickly conflict with his on-board reality. An exceedingly accomplished yachtie, Katie joins as Captain Sandy's first new Chief Stew in years. Meanwhile, the deck team discovers one of their deckhands is greener than they could imagine. By the time the first charter guests arrive, the team is left in an impossible situation that threatens to derail the season before it can even begin.

As the crew scrambles to get ready for a wedding that may or may not happen, Captain Sandy prepares to officiate for the first time. Meanwhile, Mat hopes to redeem himself after his disastrous first day and Katie sacrifices any breaks to help her team. Later that evening, the group's first night out leaves some crew members feeling the love, while others clash in a big way.