Winnie, a nuisance from Gretta's past, reemerges. Dwight is immediately taken with the beautiful, but uncommunicative, woman and vows to help right the wrong from Winnie's past.

An unfortunate love spell makes the seventh-grade paperboy, Todd, the object of Gretta's affection. Dwight and Baldric do what they can to help Gretta avoid embarrassment...and a restraining order.