Jim is reluctant to turn to Oswald for help, so Harvey pays the new crime boss a visit. Meanwhile, Jerome poses as a magician to infiltrate a children's hospital benefit, but discovers that Theo has other plans in store for him.

Theo forces Oswald to hire the Pike Brothers to torch select buildings in Gotham, and the Pikes use their sister Bridgit. Meanwhile, Theo asks Jim for his endorsement, Oswald orders Butch to lend a hand, and Leslie invites Edward and Kristen over for fondue.