Bruce's efforts in fighting crime prove less than successful until Lucius steps in. Meanwhile, Jonathan Crane goes on a rampage through Arkham as the Scarecrow, and Jim goes in alone to stop him. Elsewhere, Tabitha and Selina receive an invitation to join a new criminal enterprise.

Bruce goes to a museum curator for information on the knife, but the man is soon killed and his grandson goes on the run. Meanwhile, Edward tries to come up with a riddle worthy of his nemesis, but things don't go as planned.