While Ichabod quests on the astral plane to find the missing Abbie, Sophie comes to Joe and Jenny and asks for their help dealing with a living Gargoyle that has already killed one man.

Atticus Nevins returns to Sleepy Hollow and the group easily captures him. He explains that he unearthed a Ghoul during his time in Iraq--with August Corbin--and the group needs him to stop the creature. However, things aren't entirely as they seem. Meanwhile, Jenny meets with Ezra while Abbie contiues to cope with her time in Purgatory.