Mindy reunites with her "first kiss," Sam. The two reminisce about their time at Jewish summer camp, and soon rekindle the sparks of their teen romance.

Danny gets caught sneaking out the office supply of painkillers for his troublemaker childhood friend Stevie, who has instant chemistry with Mindy. Meanwhile, Mindy is in for a shock when Heather, Josh's ex-girlfriend who ruined Mindy's Christmas party, shows up at her doorstep to ask for her blessing to move into her apartment building. Mindy says "yes," but immediately begins to plot ways to ruin Heather's rental application.