It is the beginning of "firsts" for Mindy and Danny, as they try to set new relationship boundaries for each other in the office. Meanwhile, things get a little complicated when Jeremy tries to organize a charity event with Peter's girlfriend, Lauren; and Morgan's cousin, Lou Tookers, pays a visit to the doctor's office.

Mindy comes face-to-face with tax troubles and devises a plan to "rekindle" a fake relationship with Cliff, in order to save the practice from her fraudulent past. Meanwhile, Peter and Jeremy secretly try to outdo each other and win Lauren's love.