Mindy gets herself and Danny into trouble when she tries to fix the practice's image in the eyes of the hospital's new head of obstetrics. Meanwhile, Peter puts his grudge against Jeremy aside when he discovers that his colleague's beer pong skills could help him beat TV creator Shonda Rhimes, the reigning Dartmouth Alumni Match champion.

Mindy has no qualms about "borrowing" things that don't belong to her, until she catches Danny's mom shoplifting. Meanwhile, Peter's "dream girl," Abby, turns out to be a bit of a nightmare.