In search of a no-strings-attached hookup, Mindy dabbles with online dating. After a few embarrassing encounters, she steps up and asks for what she wants. Jody accidentally invites everyone over for a viewing party of the office's favorite TV show.

When Mindy's old flame Casey (Anders Holm) returns to New York, Mindy is confronted with the dangerous temptation of sliding back into a relationship with an ex-boyfriend.