Things seem too good to be true when Nathan and Audrey stumble across a Trouble that can resurrect the dead. They soon bring back Charlotte, but discover that resurrection comes with a terrible price. Meanwhile, Dave and Vince go hunting for Croatoan.

Duke returns to Haven with Hallie, who creates a thinny so that Nathan can recover the controller... and meet a familiar face. Meanwhile, Vince and Dwight try to find a troubled person whose ability can break Croatoan free from Dave.