Between the constant distractions of Stu, Stephie and her new boyfriend Joseph, Andrew and Zelda can't seem to get in any alone time. This causes some friction and Andrew and Stu start to look for separate apartments. Meanwhile, Big Bird recruits Lora for some girl talk as they strategize a way to get Dane to notice Big Bird.

When Andrew's ex-girlfriend Madeline crashes at Andrew's while she is town, Zelda fears she is secretly after Andrew. Feeling threatened, Zelda decides to set up Madeline with an ex-boyfriend of hers in hopes of distracting her. Adding to her stress, Zelda contemplates a major career move.