When Henry finds himself in trouble, he calls upon his Storybrooke family for help, and together they set off on a mission to find Cinderella. Along the way, Hook is confronted by an unexpected foe who threatens the group's success. In Hyperion Heights, Jacinda searches for a way to see Lucy with some unwelcome assistance from Henry, while Victoria Belfrey enlists the help of Gold and Weaver to push Henry out of the neighborhood.

Lucy runs away from Ivy, when Ivy is forced to take her trick-or-treating. Meanwhile, Tilly tells Weaver that she knows who he really is. In the past, Gold and Belle search for a way to end the Dark One's curse.