Annie decides she would like to host Thanksgiving dinner for the first time as a newly-engaged couple but Myrna, Jake's mom, has always hosted. While Myrna appears to be supportive of the change of plans, Annie quickly realizes that she is engaged in a complicated chess match over who will be the most important woman in Jake's life. Meanwhile, Gil goes in search of cheese to bring to the Thanksgiving dinner and discovers that he has a knack for fine cheese tasting. His newfound talents lead him to an underground world of exquisite and unique cheeses.

When Annie and her newly engaged dads learn that their awesome cousin "Scooby" can only attend one of their weddings, they are drawn into a subversive "bride war" over whose wedding will win out. Meanwhile, after he is stood up by Dennah and Kay, Gil bonds with a group of sixth grade boys over basketball and laser tag.