When Kay breaks up with her high-strung girlfriend Brianna, the jilted ex takes out her frustrations on Jake by wiping out his identity. Try as he might, Jake is unable to convince his human resource administrators at work that it is all a big mistake. Seizing the opportunity to become gainfully employed, Gil jumps on the job opening at Jake's company and begins bonding with everyone beautifully - much to Jake's dismay. Meanwhile, Annie, deals with her relentless and impossible-to-please boss Janet L'Amour, who becomes an ever-present fixture in Annie and Jake's life.

Gil is persuaded to do whatever it takes to win a wedding cake making contest. The unexpected return of Annie's biological mother Pam, the egg donor used by her two dads, creates family tension.