When Annie and Jake sit down to watch the highly-anticipated season finale of their favorite program "The Moors," they are shocked to discover that someone appears to have watched it already. Tensions mount and battle lines are drawn as they both vehemently proclaim their innocence. Dennah volunteers her new boyfriend Police Officer Gary Bric and his partner Officer Laguna Matata to perform a polygraph test to determine the real culprit. Everyone is surprised at the results.

Annie and Jake spontaneously decide to deface a sign in their apartment building. What they thought was a harmless joke, quickly turns into a hate-crime investigation headed by super-mom Julie, who declares she will evict whoever is responsible. Meanwhile, Gil and Dennah compete for the last "plus one" invite.