Group of criminals looking to steal a rare necklace in Tori's possession takes Cat, Tori and Tess hostage at the precinct, leaving Vincent as their only hope for help. Vincent is forced to make a decision since helping could reveal his true identity to the entire force.

In an effort to track down Sam's captor, Vincent and Cat have to work together on Valentine's Day, which forces Cat to evaluate whether she wants to be in a relationship with Gabe.