As the police search for Marley and Reese, the early morning interstate bus arrives in Patterson bringing trouble in two forms — Larry Dime, convicted pedophile and Marley's uncle who has been released on parole after 10 years in jail; and Georgia Clarke, a teenager who has seen the news and recognized Reese as her boyfriend Simon, who went missing two years earlier.

With questions hanging over Marley's return and the whereabouts of Reese, Emma brings Marley in for a formal interview. He reveals little, so Jay and Emma take him back to the shed where he was found, and their suspicion only grows. Nothing Marley says adds up with what Jay can see on the ground, and Marley is visibly shocked when they tell him that Reese is not his real name.