In the second-season premiere, the girls face the fallout from what happened with Ian at the church, and their parents have them talk with a therapist (Annabeth Gish). Meanwhile, Caleb returns to see Hanna; and Spencer is told that Toby is off-limits.

Aria takes a pottery class at a nearby college, putting her in proximity to Ezra---and Jenna. Elsewhere, Emily manipulates the truth about her swimming prospects; Hanna tries to join the yearbook staff; and Spencer grows suspicious of Jason and Melissa.