Spencer and Aria attend the Kahn brothers' party and engage in an intense game about truthfulness with Jenna. Elsewhere, Hanna receives another text regarding Caleb from "A."

Spencer uncovers Paige's violent past with Alison and warns Emily about her, but Emily is reluctant to take her advice. Meanwhile, Aria attempts to help Ezra put his past behind him, but this proves to be more difficult than she anticipated.