Joe and Frank decode a message that leads them to try and make a drop at the warehouse, despite the fact the message was intercepted by Police Chief Ezra Collig. The drop goes awry, but later when the boys return looking for more clues, they find a piece of fabric that the person fleeing the warehouse left behind. When the Tall Man escapes from the hospital, the boys reveal their entire investigation to their friends and get their help to lure the Tall Man to Chet's farm.

Frank and Callie make a visit to Rosegrave Prep where Frank learns the Dean had a close connection to his mother… one the Dean feels unsafe discussing with Frank. Joe and Biff continue to investigate the scrap of fabric from the warehouse and make a discovery that leaves Biff conflicted. Mrs. Khan makes a play for the missing piece of The Eye by enlisting the Tall Man. However, things don't exactly go as planned when the Tall Man goes after Frank and Joe to get the missing piece.