Bucket is jealous when he learns that Kelly is going to the school dance with a senior he thinks is a jerk. As he and Skinner try to sabotage her date, they start to wonder if he's not as bad as they thought.

Musician, Sara Bareilles, returns to her home town of Pacific Bluffs to hold a song writing contest. The winning song will be featured on Sara's next album. Bucket and Skinner enter the contest and win!