David's disrespect for Eli's comic book collection causes Eli to move them into a storage unit that quickly gets broken into at the same time Crawford buys a rare collection of comics for Warner as a gift. The group soon realizes that the comics belong to Eli, but Warner's not ready to give them back without a fight.

When Eli and Warner fire one of their employees right before the holiday season, the ex-game designer seeks his revenge by including an offensive word in their family-friendly Christmas game. Meanwhile, Edna encourages David to get a job as a mall Santa in order to earn enough money to buy Eli a gift.