Sherry Prather vanishes from a Florida bar and her worried mother spearheads a search for her. When Sherry's body is found by an isolated road, police discover video of Sherry riding off on a motorcycle with an unidentified man.

When pawn shop owners Mike and Angie Hockensmith and customer Dan Smith are murdered, the only eyewitness is the owners' 9-year-old son, Andrew; to solve the case, police must look into the lives of preachers and their personal grudges.