Josh wakes up to a surprising discovery that shatters his life, as well as the future he's planned with Nora. Aidan reconnects with Suzanna and remembers the life he once had while trying to stave off his hunger. Someone from Sally's past resurfaces with news that not only sends her jumping back through time, but will also change her and the roommate's lives forever.

After using magic and getting stuck in the past forever, Sally learns that she can possess herself, and realizes that by trying to change the past to match the present, she has forever changed her and the roommates' futures.