After using magic and getting stuck in the past forever, Sally learns that she can possess herself, and realizes that by trying to change the past to match the present, she has forever changed her and the roommates' futures.

Josh struggles to get Nora back in his good graces, and finds himself sucked deeper into the world of wolves whether he likes it or not, while Aidan and Sally find their bond as friends turning into something more, even though his relationship with Suzanna has taken a new turn.