Every NFL team covets the Lombardi trophy, named after one of the most legendary icons in NFL history. Peyton and Eli Manning go on a journey to discover the history behind the trophy and attempt to recreate the original prototype. 

Brett Favre, Eric Dickerson and Emmitt Smith have achieved milestones that no player is likely to equal. While discussing whether their marks will stand the test of time, Peyton visits Smith's memorabilia storage unit, dons Dickerson's goggles and shares cheese curds with Favre.