After almost half a century, Peyton tries to solve the mystery of what really happened during "The Immaculate Reception". With the help of Franco Harris, Frenchy Fuqua, Terry Bradshaw and Phil Villapiano, Peyton re-enacts the play known as the NFL's Zapruder Film.

Peyton meets up with his greatest rival, Tom Brady, to hit golf balls off Jim Nantz's home and reminisce about their epic battles.