Vintage memorabilia collector David Schafer has spent decades assembling the toys, comic books, and other collectibles from his childhood - all in strikingly pristine condition. David shares some of his rarest and most valuable items, including a Batman and Justice League playset released at the height of the Caped Crusader's 1966 popularity; a Mad Magazine straitjacket that was available by mail only; and the 1941 comic that features the first appearance of Wonder Woman. Joining Lisa is "Collector's Call" favorite Joel Magee, a.k.a. America's Toy Scout. Joel appraises the entirety of David's dazzling collection, then makes a trade offer for one of David's Disney rarities. The show concludes with David unveiling to Lisa a 1982 Mad Magazine parody of "The Facts of Life."

Andrew Somer has a heart that's three apples tall, and it's filled with Smurf collectables. After a lifetime of collecting Smurf memorabilia, Andrew is ready to share his incredible Smurf room with Lisa Whelchel and expert appraiser and toy shop owner, John Ragusa. Together, they go deep into the world of blue creatures and hidden villages, checking out one-of-a-kind wax prototypes from the 80s, an entire end cap shelf display, and even a letter from the daughter of Peyo, the creator of the Smurfs characters. As a collector, Andrew is particularly a fan of store display pieces, and John Ragusa attempts to trade one of Andrew's prized display stands for a one-of-its-kind keychain display.